Bucket Mouse Trap Doesn’t Work (7 Reasons + Fixes)

I’ve been using bucket mouse traps for the last 5 years in my house. Although they worked great at first, the mice seem more cautious now and avoid my bucket traps.

So, why bucket mouse trap doesn’t work?

There’s a high chance that you’re using the wrong bait in the wrong location. It can be the case that there’re not enough traps or even too many baits.

Also, if you handle the bait with your bare hands, the mice smell it and avoid those baits. So, be careful in preparing the bait and the setup for the bucket mouse trap.

 Now, Follow the article to find out in detail what are the reasons and the fixes.

Bucket Mouse Trap Doesn’t Work: Quick Overview

Well, let’s get a quick look at why your bucket mouse trap won’t work and the fixes. Remember, these are the most common reasons and solutions for your household. You can always experiment with the trap for unique problems.

Reasons Solutions
Using the wrong bait Use a different, stronger bait.
Incorrect baiting Put the bait in the proper location of the trap.
Too many baits Reduce the number of baits and place them strategically.
Human scent Use gloves when preparing bait.
Wrong trap location Place the trap in a proper location.
Not enough traps Use multiple traps.
Ineffective trap Use different types of traps.

Well, these are the most common scenarios where your bucket mouse trap won’t work. Now, let’s get into the details of how you can solve the issue and catch more mice.

Solution 1: Use A Different Bait

Using the same bait continuously can be an issue why your bucket mouse trap is not working. Try to use some different baits. You can use peanut butter or cheese, cereal, soft candies, strong-smelled cheese, gumdrops, etc.

Nuts and seeds are preferred more by mice than cheese. And if food items do not work, try using nesting materials such as cotton, or dental floss. These will attract more mice at a time.

Solution 2: Place The Bait Properly

Do not put the bait on the top of the pedal on your bucket mouse trap. Try putting it underneath the pedal.

bucket mouse trap bait properly

Source: fivegallonideas.com

Thus, it will attract the mice to come beneath the pedal to retrieve the bait. This will increase the chance for the mice to fall into the trap.

Solution 3: Use A Proper Amount of Baits

Do not use too many baits at a time. Mice can easily retrieve solid and heavy foods.

So, use a small amount of food or bait items to catch the mice in the trap. Use only a pea-sized amount of bait. It will be enough to lure the mice but not too much.

[amazon box=”B07FJXSZTS” template=”horizontal”]

Solution 4: Don’t Give Away Human Scent

Mice can smell the human scent and avoid things with human scent. So, to not give away human scent, wear gloves when preparing the bait and bucket mouse trap.

Solution 5: Place The Trap in The Proper Location

Mice venture into the dark places of your home and near the walls. So, you’ll need to set the bucket mouse trap in dark places and near the walls.

Also, set the traps facing the wall.

Solution 6: Use Multiple Traps

Do not get stuck using only a bucket mouse trap. Even if you use only bucket traps, place multiple ones and set them 2-3 feet apart.

bucket mouse multiple traps

Source: backyardchickens.com

Also, you can put multiple traps where there is increased rodent activity.

Solution 7: Use Different Traps

Use different bait and traps around the house to catch more mice at a time. Change the bait every 4 to 6 weeks.

Different Traps

Source: nytimes.com

It’s effective to use different types of traps as well. You can use snap traps, glue traps, live traps, etc. apart from using bucket traps.

How to Stop Mice from Entering Your House: Some Tips

You may be wondering how you can stop the mice from invading your house. The question you should ask yourself is, what scares mice the most?

Well, there are many things, as I have prepared a list of things you can use:

  • Mice are scared of bright light and loud noises. So, it’s a good idea to maintain your home so that there is enough light.
  • Mice hate the smell of peppermint oil, cayenne pepper, and cloves. Soak a cotton ball with this oil and leave them in places where you’ve had mice problems.
  • Seal up any cracks and holes in your house with cement or metal.
  • Store your food in airtight containers and dispose of the garbage on a regular basis.
  • Set up traps outside your house in dark places and near the walls.

Slight regular house maintenance will keep your house clean from any mice or rodents. And if you want to know does home defense kill roaches, well there’s a remedy for that too.


What Are Mice Most Attracted to?

Mice are most attracted to cereal, butter, bacon, sweets, meats, paper, clothes, burlaps, seeds, water, tissues, etc. These things are the most common household things that attract mice.

Will A Mouse Bite You?

Mice usually do not bite unless it has to, especially when you catch them. But the risk is the health hazards and diseases they bring with them.

What Happens If A Mouse Scratch You?

Mouse bites are not usually serious to your health, but to be on the safe side, you should see a doctor. There is always a risk of infection and as mice carry bacteria and viruses, it can even lead to lethal issues.


So, if your bucket mouse trap doesn’t work, try the solutions I gave you.

Also, you can opt for other mouse trap options as there are many mouse traps in the market. Set up multiple types of traps around the house. Thus, stay clear of the annoying rodents in your home.