Pestie vs Ortho Home Defense (Which is Better)

In the hunt for DIY pest control options in the market? You’ve surely heard of Pestie and Ortho Home Defense.

So, which DIY pest control is better in Pestie vs Ortho Home Defense?

In the Pestie vs. Ortho Home Defense battle, Pestie is better if you want custom pest control. It has customized plans and a targeted approach that effectively tackles over 100 pests. On the other hand, Ortho Home Defense offers provides protection against selective indoor and outdoor pests. 

In today’s article, we’ll figure out how the two different services differ. Let’s begin.

Pestie vs Ortho Home Defense: Key Differences

Pestie and Ortho Home Defense provide completely different pest control services. To get a basic understanding of how they differ, we will compare them head-to-head.

We’ll compare Pestie with Ortho Home Defense based on the type of service, active ingredients, target pest, effectiveness, safety, and cost.

Here are the key differences between Pestie and Ortho Home Defense:

Aspects Pestie Ortho Home Defense
Service Type Both subscription and one-time purchase One-time Purchase
Active Ingredients Varies depending on the pest problem Bifenthrin 0.05%, Zeta-Cypermethrin 0.01%
Effectiveness Varies depending on the product 12-month protection indoors, 3-month protection outdoors
Target Pest Spiders, Ants, Cockroaches, Fleas, Ticks, Beetles, Earwigs, Mites Ants, cockroaches, spiders, fleas, ticks, scorpions, beetles, earwigs, silverfish, centipedes and millipedes
Safety Relatively safe Relatively unsafe
Convenience Highly convenient Less Convenient
Free Shipping Available N/A
Price Expensive Budget-friendly

Pestie vs Ortho Home Defense: Detailed Differences

Alright, it’s time to take a detailed look at the two DIY pest control services. 

Check out all the segments below to figure out which one does a better job at meeting your demands.

Service Type

Pestie offers three different purchase plans for the customer. But Ortho Home Defense doesn’t have any customized plans. They provide a range of pest-control products. 

Here are the three different plans Pestie provides:

  • Yearly subscription
  • Pay each application
  • One-time purchase

Depending on your convenience, you can pick any of their plans.

On the other hand, Ortho Home Defense is available for a one-time purchase.

Some of the popular Ortho Home Defense products include:

  • Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer with Trigger Sprayer
  • Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer Refill
  • Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer Concentrate
  • Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer with Comfort Wand
  • Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer Ready to Use

You need to choose the product yourself in case of Ortho Home Defense. 

Here are the pros and cons of the two pest control options given below. This will help you to identify which option will be more appropriate for you.

Pros Cons
Pestie Pestie offers personalized pest control plans based on your location and pest problems.

Pestie’s plans cover a wide array of pests, addressing more than 100 different insect species.

Allows homeowners to take control of their pest management through DIY applications.

Using Pestie requires time and effort on the homeowner’s part.

Pestle doesn’t offer immediate expert intervention.

Does not guarantee 100% effectiveness.

Ortho Home Defense Effective in controlling a range of indoor and outdoor pests.

Offers long-lasting pest protection.

Ortho Home Defense products can be used both indoors and outdoors.

Contains chemical ingredients, which can be a health concern.

Active Ingredients

Pestie provides a customized package consisting of varying active ingredients, whereas Ortho Home Defense contains Bifenthrin(0.05%) and Zeta-Cypermethrin(0.01%) as active ingredients.

Bifenthrin is a powerful insecticide that targets the nervous system of pests. It disrupts their ability to transmit signals by affecting tiny gates on nerve cells, hindering their normal functioning. Bifenthrin actively kills bugs and other similar pests.

Zeta-cypermethrin is a contact insecticide, which works when insects come into direct contact with it or ingest it. This pesticide is effective against various insects, including beetles, aphids, and several types of Lepidoptera (butterflies and moths).

On the contrary, Pestie doesn’t mention their product’s active ingredients anywhere on their website. They claim to use different active ingredients for other pesticides to suit your needs.

However, Pestie ingredients mostly consist of synthetic chemical products which kill a wide range of pests. 

Target Pest

Pestie offers pest control products for 100+ pests whereas the number is more than 130 for Ortho Home Defense. 

So, what bugs does pestie kill?

Pestie kills spiders, ants, cockroaches, fleas, ticks, beetles, earwigs, mites, and other common pests. Despite covering a wide spectrum of household pests, Pestie doesn’t offer treatments for termites or bed bugs.

They will provide you with customized, pest-specific pest control products. 

In contrast, Ortho Home Defense can kill and repel ants, cockroaches, spiders, fleas, ticks, scorpions, beetles, earwigs, silverfish, centipedes, and millipedes effectively.


Pestie effectively kills and fends off pests from coming back for 2-3 months. Compared to Pestie, Ortho Home Defense provides protection against pests for a longer time period. 

The optimized pest control plan by Pestie allows you to build a bug barrier around your home. 

Pestie delivers products tailored to your location and timing, all while considering built-in resistance management. There’s no need for you to keep track of when to reapply. 

Plus, everything you require comes in the package. They come with user-friendly videos and accessible expert customer support ready to assist you whenever you need them. No wonder why pestie reviews are always highly positive!

Again, Ortho Home Defense is a reliable solution for tackling both indoor and outdoor insect problems. It works as a preventive treatment or can be applied when you notice insect activity. 

The Ortho Home Defense flying bug killer provides a bug barrier that lasts up to 12 months indoors. It offers long-lasting protection against ants, roaches, and spiders on indoor nonporous surfaces.

Used outdoors, Ortho Home Defense can effectively fend off the pests for up to 3 months. You get a similar outcome with Home Defense Max compared to Standard Home Defense.


Pestie stands out in convenience, offering tailored pest control solutions delivered right to your doorstep. On the flip side, Ortho Home Defense provides one-time purchase options with easy availability in local stores. 

While Pestie streamlines the process with scheduled deliveries and support, Ortho Home Defense offers immediate accessibility. 

With subscription options and customized plans, Pestle is a hassle-free way to keep pests at bay. 

You’ll have to wait to get your Pestie products delivered to you, which can take a while. However, you’re likely to get Ortho Home Defense in your local retail stores.

The choice depends on your preference for a subscription-based model or a single-purchase option. So, you need to get the pest control according to your convenience and your preferred way of pest control.


When it comes to pest control solutions, customers tend to take safety as a top consideration. 

That leads us to question, is Pestie safe?

Yes, Pestie is safe. They ensure that all their products are safe for use around children and pets. These plant-based products utilize a micro-encapsulated formula, ensuring effectiveness even during rainy weather. 

You can spray Pestie products on plants, trees, bushes, and grass, but avoid using them on fruits or vegetables.

Let’s talk about the other option now. Is Home Defense safe?

Yes, Ortho Home Defense is generally safe for use. But like all pesticides, it can pose risks to you, your family, or your pets if not used properly. Always follow the specific safety guidelines on the label of the product, which you should review before using any new pesticide.

The primary safety concerns with this product lie in its potential environmental impact. Research indicates that bifenthrin, the active ingredient in Ortho Home Defense, significantly contributes to insecticide toxicity in water. It poses a threat to aquatic life compared to similar chemicals. 

So, it’s crucial to steer clear of lakes, streams, ponds, or drainage ditches when using this product.


Pestie is a slightly more expensive option than Ortho Home Defense. 

Depending on their three separate plans, Pestie can charge anywhere from $39 to $136

Pestie offers a one-time application service at $49. Customers opting for an annual subscription or paying per application enjoy a reduced rate. 

Specifically, for an annual subscription, Pestie charges $29 per application, amounting to a prepayment of $116.

This might rub some customers the wrong way as it’s not cheap by any means.

So, they tend to lean towards Ortho Home Defense as it’s a much cheaper and cost-effective option. You have to spend half the amount of Pestie services if you want to go along with Ortho Home Defense. 

Verdict: Which Pest Control Should You Choose? 

Alright. We’ve laid out every possible information differentiating the two DIY pest control services. It’s time to find out which is convenient for whom. 

For those seeking convenience, customization, and a comprehensive approach to pest control, Pestie is the go-to choice. You’ll get help from professionals directly in dealing with various pest problems. 

The ease of scheduled deliveries and expert support adds to its appeal though Pestie comes at a higher cost. Moreover, those who prefer plant-based, environmentally-friendly products will appreciate Pestie’s safety measures.

On the other hand, Ortho Home Defense is a solid option for cost-conscious consumers seeking an effective, one-time solution. It’s best for people who have experience in pest control to some extent. Specifically, it’s suitable for those who are dealing with a particular kind of pest issue. 


What brands are similar to Pestie?

ServiceMaster, Bob Martin, and Bug Brasil are three brands similar to Pestie. 

Does Ortho Home Defense ever go bad?

Ortho Home Defense Insect Killer can go bad after 3 years. The chemical properties of the pesticide will slowly start losing its effectiveness after the given period.

Can I spray Ortho on my bed?

Yes, you can spray Ortho on your bed. Also, you can spray it around bed frames, headboards, floors, carpeting, baseboards, furniture, molding, ceilings, and walls.


Now that you’ve finished reading about Pestie vs Ortho, we hope you can pick the right DIY pest control.

Keep the pricing and usage in mind before picking your favored service. We encourage you to explore your options before picking the right option for you.